The 4 Essential Keys to Building Your Handmade Brand Off Etsy or Amazon Taking the leap from a marketplace like Etsy or Amazon to your own website can be both exciting and terrifying. It’s like stepping out into the big, wide world without the built-in safety net of an existing audience. If you’re thinking, "I’ll just build my site, and customers will come in droves," I have some news for you: If you build it, they will NOT come. At least, not without some serious effort on your part.
But don’t worry! This isn’t meant to discourage you—it’s meant to prepare you for what you need to truly succeed. And trust me, it’s doable. The secret sauce is a mix of traffic, a solid sales funnel, the right tools, and a mindset that’s ready to adapt and grow.
The 4 Biggest Things You Need for Success
1. Traffic
Traffic is the lifeblood of your business, but unlike Etsy or Amazon, there’s no one to drive traffic for you. You have to get creative in bringing customers to your site. This can be done through:
SEO and Content Creation: Craft keyword-rich blog posts, product descriptions, and content that speaks to your audience. This will help you organically show up in search engines.
Social Media: Platforms like Instagram, Pinterest, and TikTok can drive massive amounts of traffic to your shop. You need to post consistently and strategically to attract potential customers.
Paid Ads: Facebook, Google, and Instagram ads can be a quick way to generate traffic. While this requires an upfront investment, paid ads can lead to a significant return if done right.
Real-World Example: When I first launched my own Shopify site after years on Etsy (I wish I had done it sooner), I quickly realized my existing followers weren’t enough to generate consistent sales. I started running Facebook ads targeting lookalike audiences based on my Etsy customers. Within a few months, my site traffic had increased by 50%, and more importantly, sales were coming in daily.
2. Sales Funnel
A sales funnel is essentially the customer’s journey from first discovering you to making a purchase, and it’s critical for driving sales. Here’s how to think about it:
Awareness: The customer finds you—via social media, SEO, or ads.
Engagement: They explore your website, read your blog, or follow you on Instagram.
Consideration: They sign up for your email list or follow you on social media. Maybe they add items to their cart.
Decision: They make the purchase!
To make this work, you need to keep your funnel full at all times. That means constantly attracting new visitors (traffic) and nurturing them through your funnel with engaging content and offers.
3. Mindset
Running your own website requires more than just technical know-how—it requires a strong mindset. There will be days when things don’t go as planned: Ads don’t perform, sales drop, or a product launch flops. You’ll need resilience and grit to push through these challenges.
Here’s the mindset shift that helped me:
Test, Rinse, Repeat: Not everything will work the first time. Be ready to pivot and make adjustments along the way.
Progress Over Perfection: It’s better to launch an imperfect site and improve it as you go than wait for it to be perfect. You’ll learn more from being live than from endless tweaks.
Pro Tip: Keep a "Wins Journal" to track every small victory, from your first sale to your first 5-star review. This will keep you motivated and remind you of the progress you’re making, even when things feel slow.
4. Consistency & Automation
To build a thriving brand, consistency is key. Whether it’s creating new content, sending out regular email newsletters, or consistently engaging on social media, your audience needs to hear from you regularly. Consider using tools that allow you to automate parts of your business:
Email Marketing: Tools like Klaviyo or MailChimp can automate welcome emails, abandoned cart sequences, and regular newsletters, saving you tons of time while still keeping you top of mind for your customers.
Social Media Schedulers: Tools like Later or Buffer can help schedule posts across multiple platforms, ensuring you’re consistently active even when you’re busy with other tasks.
Test, Measure, Optimize
The journey to building your own brand is not linear. There will be ups, downs, and a few unexpected turns along the way. The key to success? Testing what works, measuring the results, and then optimizing. This could mean tweaking your sales funnel, trying new traffic sources, or refining your email campaigns.
Ask yourself these questions:
Are my traffic sources bringing the right customers to my site?
Where are customers dropping off in my sales funnel? Can I tweak the copy or design to guide them through more easily?
Am I consistently engaging with my audience on social media and through email?
Real-World Results from My Journey
I’ve experienced this firsthand. After leaving Etsy, I faced challenges with traffic and maintaining consistent sales. But once I optimized my traffic channels and built out a strong sales funnel, things began to flow. I still test, tweak, and optimize, but now I have a system that works, and you can do the same.
The truth is, it’s one part mindset, one part grit. Test, rinse, and repeat. And know that the rewards—building your own brand and owning your customer relationships—are worth every bit of effort.
Conclusion: Building your brand outside of a marketplace like Etsy or Amazon might be challenging, but it’s also incredibly empowering. You control your traffic, your sales, and your growth. Start with these four pillars: traffic, a solid sales funnel, mindset, and consistency. In a year from now, you’ll be amazed at how far you’ve come.
Comments